Today's post:
Why Richard Dawkins Was Simply Wrong in His “Reason Rally” Speech
When the gods are shaken from the sky,
there's a scientific reason why.
There's no wish to replace them
and no-one's rushing in to win
the race to fill the empty space
— All About Eve, "Outshine The Sun"
Today's post:
Does the Bible Say All Atheists are Intellectually Dishonest?
This is another round in the argument with Koukl over Romans 1:18ff, and at this stage it descends into argument about whether the passages in question actually support Koukl's position. The alternative view (which I linked in the earlier post on this argument) of how to construe the Greek text (in the absence of punctuation) is of course not addressed.
Today's post:
Do Atheists Simply Repress Their Knowledge of God?
This is Feser's corner of a recent multi-way argument between apologist Greg Koukl, Randal Rauser, Feser, and atheist Jeff Lowder. Unsurprisingly Feser thinks that the Thomist perspective is the only right answer, but at least he has the apparent intellectual honesty to reject Koukl's nonsense.
But there's a wildcard in here that I didn't see mentioned by anyone involved. (I'd skimmed parts of this exchange on Rauser's blog and links before seeing this post). Koukl is using the usual “without excuse” clobber passage from Romans 1:18-20:
Today's post:
Yesterday's post:
Today's post, from an atheist (Todd Stiefel) for a change:
Today's post:
The Dogmas and Failure of Rational Atheism
Usual drivel. Criticizes Harris' The End Of Faith as though it were the be-all and end-all of atheist criticism of religion; spouts typical nonsense about things like the Golden Rule (which predates not only Christianity but even Judaism, and was independently stated in philosophies such as Confucianism) and the consequences of atheism.
Today's post:
The 6 Varieties of Atheism (and Which Are Most Defensible)
Unsurprisingly, Feser fails to avoid taking his usual potshots at his bêtes noires, the "New Atheists". Other than that his categorization is quite simplistic (and fascinating in that he doesn't seem to notice that he defines 9 varieties, not 6).
A subversion of the usual rule about headline questions: Barron thinks the answer is “no”, but he is wrong :-)
Today, an interview with an atheist commenter for a change:
Today's post:
Today's post:
For all that this is from Paul Rimmer rather than one of the usual suspects, it still earns the drivel tag honestly.
Today's post:
Is Richard Dawkins Close to Christianity?
More confirmation of that law about questions in headlines.
Today's post:
Do ‘Religiously Knowledgeable’ Atheists Believe in God?
Short version: survey statistics are not worth much, especially in fringe small-N subcategories of larger surveys. (A proportion — sometimes a nontrivial one — of any survey sample are people giving a purely random or maliciously hostile response; for unpopular or socially marginalized beliefs this can easily skew the results. It has also been found that Americans overstate their religious observance and beliefs to pollsters.)
Today's post:
10 Atheists Who Engage Religion Charitably
More of the "good" vs. "bad" atheist drivel.
Today's post:
Today's post discusses the definition of the word "atheism". Yawn.
How Should We Define ‘Atheism’?
That said, I find Ruse (an arch-accomodationist atheist who also identifies as agnostic) and Bullivant (a Catholic) to be rather odd choices to edit the "Oxford Handbook of Atheism". Ruse has spent years engaging in unwarranted and unjustified attacks on other atheists (see for example Rosenhouse here and here or Coyne here). Anyone read the book or seen a useful review?
Today's post is Trent Horn's review of Peter Boghossian's book: