Today's post, in which Robert Barron goes to the movies again:
“Risen” and the Reality of the Resurrection
Nothing to see here.
When the gods are shaken from the sky,
there's a scientific reason why.
There's no wish to replace them
and no-one's rushing in to win
the race to fill the empty space
— All About Eve, "Outshine The Sun"
Today's post, in which Robert Barron goes to the movies again:
“Risen” and the Reality of the Resurrection
Nothing to see here.
Today's post:
Doubting Jesus: A Catholic Biblical Scholar Responds to Skeptical Questions
So here we have Pitre's response to a handful of the questions posted a couple of weeks back, and it's... pretty pathetic.
Many of the questions answered are of course from believers, not atheists, and many of the questions chosen are not actually relevant. Pitre is apparently completely committed to the ‘traditional’ authorship of the Gospels, never mind the extensive contradictory evidence, and he presupposes the literal truth of whichever part of whichever Gospel he wants to use to answer any other question. This isn't scholarship, this is pure apologetics.
Today's post:
Atheists: What Question Would You Ask a Catholic Biblical Scholar?
Vogt says he's after questions from atheists; we should collect some possible questions here if one of the un-banned is willing to forward them...
This article from last Christmas has been recycled to the SN front page with today's date (but still has its original comment thread.
I responded to several of its points in the original EN posting, so I'm not opening a new comment thread for it at this time; use the original one.
Today's post:
Does the Bible Affirm the Existence of Mythical Creatures?
Translation issues aside, the obvious answer is "yes" — angels and talking snakes come to mind as examples.
Today's post (well, it was today's when I started, probably yesterday's by the time this is done):
How Richard Dawkins Helps Prove Biblical Inspiration
The ‘bronze-age goat-herders / desert tribes / whatever’ dismissal of the Bible is probably the atheist meme that I find most annoying. It's true that the Old Testament portrays itself—and of course not merely the Protestant fundamentalists but also a substantial Catholic traditionalist contingent concurs in this—as containing a record of bronze-age events and individuals; but this position has long since ceased to be tenable.
As usual, though, Heschmeyer fails to make any kind of credible response.
Today's post:
Does the Bible Support Same-Sex Marriage?
As I believe I've mentioned before, I am, as an atheist, entirely in favour of the Catholic church (and other churches) harping on sexual issues as much as possible, because it's the most effective way of both undercutting their claim to moral authority and driving away many members. (The 2009 Pew survey showed that the top reasons given for leaving the Catholic church—all ranked above the abuse scandals—were the church's positions on homosexuality, abortion, contraception, and divorce, and the status of women.)
Today's post:
Does Evolution Contradict Genesis?
Very superficial, little more than a criticism of six-day creation interpretations of Genesis.
Oh dear, looks like today is “frantically try and paper over the awkward bits in the Bible” day:
Do the “Infancy Narratives” of Matthew and Luke Contradict Each Other?
This one is so bad it could have come from AIG; Staples' tries to reconcile the question of where Joseph and Mary lived (Luke says Nazareth, with a visit to Bethlehem for the census; Matthew implies they lived at Bethlehem until forced to flee) by arguing that Matthew doesn't actually say that the house where the Magi visited Jesus was in Bethlehem rather than Nazareth. He chooses to ignore:
All in all it's absolutely clear that the author of GMatthew did not believe that Jesus and his family had been anywhere but Bethlehem before their flight. (It's also absolutely clear that he cares nothing about facts, since every single step in this story is explicitly stated to “fulfill what had been spoken” in various scraps of Jewish scripture.)
To claim as Staples does that the author of Matthew simply chose not to mention Nazareth earlier is to do violence to the text as written; a classic example of reading into a text something which is not there, with no justification.
Also, of course, this one point barely scratches the surface of the contradictions between Matthew and Luke, the contradictions between both and actual history, and the contradictions between Matthew and Luke's infancy stories and Mark's portrayal of Jesus' family.
Today's post:
Richard Dawkins and the God of the Old Testament
As usual, the elephant in the room goes unremarked: the Old Testament (specifically the parts under discussion here) is not factual history but propaganda. Evolution may be harsh and amoral, but it really happened; we are the result of hundreds of millions of years of tooth-and-claw survival. But rather than deify evolution and worship its values, we have the option—some would say the only right option on meeting a god—of killing it and taking its powers for our own use.
The Old Testament God has no such excuse. The stories of genocides were almost certainly not told because they actually happened, but rather because the compilers of the OT regarded these genocidal commands as being consistent with the kind of god that they wanted; they embraced the idea of slaughter rather than rejecting it. (Archaeology gives us a history of the Levant which is completely at odds with the OT stories until sometime after the time of Solomon; we obviously can't prove that something didn't happen, but we can establish that the context of the genocide stories does not fit with the historical context of any plausible time at which they could have occurred.)
So what path to choose? Worship of a God whose supposedly inspired literature contains fictional atrocities, or look at the cold facts of evolution and say, “yes, this is where we came from, and we need to understand the legacy it has left us; but it no longer dictates our future”?
Today's post:
Today's post:
Periodically on SN the issue comes up of the “traditional” authorship and dating of the gospels, as opposed to the modern scholarly conclusions. The latest advocate of the traditional position is one “Irenaeus of New York” (one wonders what happened to the real-names policy), who endorses not only Matthean priority but also the idea that Matthew was originally written in a Semitic language (Hebrew or Aramaic).
So I thought a post reviewing the evidence and some resources would be useful.
Today's article:
Today's post: