Today's post:
When the gods are shaken from the sky,
there's a scientific reason why.
There's no wish to replace them
and no-one's rushing in to win
the race to fill the empty space
— All About Eve, "Outshine The Sun"
Thursday, 7 July 2016
Wednesday, 27 April 2016
Estranged Notions: Why Miracles Are Not Incompatible with Science
Yesterday's post:
Why Miracles Are Not Incompatible with Science
“not incompatible”—as long as you define ‘law of nature’ in a useless way.
Wednesday, 20 April 2016
Estranged Notions: What Constitutes a Miracle?
Today's post:
Wednesday, 24 February 2016
Estranged Notions: Is It Reasonable to Believe in Miracles?
Today's post:
Is It Reasonable to Believe in Miracles?
Broussard makes a bit of a dog's breakfast out of what is actually a fairly straightforward subject. Hume had it right in what the modern Bayesian recognizes as being the precisely correct way: a hypothesis with low prior probability has to be supported by evidence which would be more improbable were the hypothesis false.
Broussard's examples all either ignore major relevant evidence or make Hume's argument a strawman (or both). Why do we believe that the Big Bang happened? We have evidence that not only would be vastly improbable had it not happened, but which was predicted in advance from theory, which eliminates a whole class of post-hoc justification biases. We don't say that scientific laws can't be revised, because the revised laws must not be inconsistent with the previously established evidence, while new evidence may be inconsistent with the old laws. Hume never said that merely being rare would make it impossible to believe in some event; indeed, he gives examples of the kind of evidence that would justify belief even in highly unlikely propositions.
So Broussard's claim that Hume is setting too high a bar is completely unjustified, and the modern Bayesian knows (as Hume did not) that this can be justified mathematically.
And then the whole thing degenerates into farce when Broussard claims that human activities such as lying or stealing bodies are somehow more improbable than an actual resurrection of a dead person. And the argumentum ad martyrdom is ridiculous: we have no good reason to believe that any church figure from the 1st century was martyred at all, and we especially do not have any reason to believe that of any actual disciple of Jesus.
Monday, 19 October 2015
Estranged Notions: Trial by Fire: Modernity’s Response to Miracles
Today's post:
Trial by Fire: Modernity’s Response to Miracles
Heschmeyer apparently wants to believe that all those people who passed their trial-by-ordeal in the early middle ages were the beneficiaries of actual miracles, rather than that the priests were systematically fudging the trials.
Friday, 4 September 2015
Estranged Notions: Is the Shroud of Turin a Genuine Miracle?
Today's post:
Is the Shroud of Turin a Genuine Miracle?
We have of course heard previously from Longenecker on exactly this subject here.
Friday, 8 May 2015
Monday, 9 March 2015
Estranged Notions: The Bible and the Question of Miracles: Towards a Christian Response
Today's post:
The Bible and the Question of Miracles: Towards a Christian Response
As a ‘response’ this is of course completely inadequate.
Saturday, 21 February 2015
Monday, 3 November 2014
Estranged Notions: Prayer, Science, and the Existence of God
Today's post:
Friday, 10 October 2014
Estranged Notions: Does the Shroud of Turin Prove God?
Today's post:
Friday, 12 September 2014
Estranged Notions: David Hume, Miracles, and the Resurrection
Today's post:
Tuesday, 8 April 2014
Guest Post: David Hume on Miracles
This is a guest post; the views expressed are those of the contributor, and not of the site owner.
by Fr. Sean
David Hume was one of the most brilliant Scottish philosophers of the 18th century. Among his many works, he wrote a book entitled: An Enquiry into Human Understanding. In chapter ten of the book, he establishes a framework for entertaining the possibility of a miracle. If by chance you aren’t familiar with it, read part 1 and part 2; http://www.bartleby.com/37/3/14.html
Wednesday, 5 March 2014
Estranged Notions: Can an Atheist Scientist Believe in Miracles?
Today's post:
Friday, 31 January 2014
Estranged Notions: The Rational Judgment of a Miraculous Cure
Today's post descends into the "medical miracles" cesspit:
The Rational Judgment of a Miraculous Cure
(Number of amputees healed: 0)