Tuesday's post:
When the gods are shaken from the sky,
there's a scientific reason why.
There's no wish to replace them
and no-one's rushing in to win
the race to fill the empty space
— All About Eve, "Outshine The Sun"
Thursday, 22 June 2017
Sunday, 9 October 2016
Ozy Frantz contra John C. Wright on sexual morality
Wright's conversion story (warning, have barf bag ready before reading, it's pretty bad even by SN standards) went up on SN in the relatively early days. One of Wright's claims in it is that as an atheist he had argued himself, by means of nothing but ‘pure’ ‘rational’ philosophy into positions otherwise held by Christians; his conversion story doesn't go into details about what those were, but from his other writings it seems clear that sexual matters were at least a significant part of this.
So I was interested (and amused) to see that Ozy Frantz has done a long takedown:
John C Wright is an absolutely delightful person whose blog posts have given me endless hours of enjoyment and who has recommended many excellent short stories (admittedly, by talking about how they are the Morlockian death of science fiction, but a good recommender is a good recommender, even if it’s wired backwards). I have recently discovered an old blog post of his which purported to lay out natural and worldly reasons why a rational atheist should follow Christian sexual morality. As an atheist libertine, I find this a tremendously interesting proposal and wish to argue with it.
Against John C Wright’s On The Sexual Nature of Man, Part The First
Against John C Wright’s On The Sexual Nature of Man, Part The Second
Against John C Wright’s On The Sexual Nature of Man, Part The Third
Against John C Wright’s On The Sexual Nature of Man, Part The Fourth
Against John C Wright’s On The Sexual Nature of Man, Part the Last
Friday, 7 October 2016
Estranged Notions: Getting Morality Wrong
Yesterday's post (after 3 weeks of silence):
In which Joe Heschmeyer seems more concerned with the headline than the content:
Wednesday, 24 August 2016
Estranged Notions: Learning Morality from Bill and Ted
Today's post:
Wednesday, 30 March 2016
Estranged Notions: The “3:10 to Yuma” Proof of God
A post! Only been two whole weeks since the last one…
The “3:10 to Yuma” Proof of God
In this one, Gordon attempts to top Kreeft's “Argument from Bach” with an “Argument from Western Movies”.
Wednesday, 2 December 2015
Estranged Notions: What Do You Think of the Moral Argument for God?
Today's post:
Tuesday, 22 September 2015
Estranged Notions: Why Your Life Does Not Belong to You
Yesterday's post:
Why Your Life Does Not Belong to You
The most obvious issue with this post is that it makes no attempt whatsoever to actually answer the question implied by the title.
Wednesday, 27 May 2015
Estranged Notions: Is “Heaven” to Blame for Murder?
Today's post:
Is “Heaven” to Blame for Murder?
Horn incorrectly frames an argument (concerning the Janzen murder/suicide case) as being a fallacious appeal to consequences, by conflating the concepts of “X is true” and “belief in X is good”; the first is a fact question, the second a value question.
For bonus points, Horn then proceeds to gratuitously bring in the issue of homosexuality. I find myself very much in favour of this move and think that Catholic apologists should engage in it whenever possible; the more that they harp on it, the more it diminishes their credibility in modern society.
Friday, 22 May 2015
Estranged Notions: Abortion, Souls, and the Atheist Conundrum
Round three of Heschmeyer vs. Dillon on abortion:
Wednesday, 13 May 2015
Estranged Notions: Do You Need God to Know That Abortion is Wrong?
Oh dear.
Do You Need God to Know That Abortion is Wrong?
I don't know whether this is deliberate dishonesty or egregious error: the article has a graph[edit: see below] supposedly showing the "latest" polling data on abortion but which is actually from 2012. This isn't because the whole article is recycled, either, because it is responding to a piece in The New Republic from last month.
Monday, 11 May 2015
Estranged Notions: “The Avengers” and Friedrich Nietzsche
Today's post:
“The Avengers” and Friedrich Nietzsche
Blah blah Nietzsche blah blah Ubermenschen blah blah Nazis blah blah.
Wednesday, 4 March 2015
Estranged Notions: Stem Cell Research and ‘Science vs. Religion’
Today's post:
Stem Cell Research and ‘Science vs. Religion’
You'd think that after that Donohue post, anything would be an improvement, but this one tries hard to prove that wrong.
Wednesday, 28 January 2015
Estranged Notions: Why Having a Heart of Gold is Not What Christianity is About
Today's post:
Why Having a Heart of Gold is Not What Christianity is About
So apparently Christianity isn't about ethics but rather “the explosive emergence of a new world”. 2000 years on, and the same old world is turning just as it always did. Isn't this argument starting to wear a bit thin?
Saturday, 29 November 2014
Estranged Notions: What Racism Reveals About God and Man
Belated link to yesterday's post:
What Racism Reveals About God and Man
As usual, there is no actual attempt to engage with secular concepts of ethics, just a brute denial that they exist. (Really need an even more disparaging tag than "drivel" for these kinds of posts.)
Wednesday, 15 October 2014
Estranged Notions: On the So-Called “Choice-in-Dying”
Today's post, on a topic I don't think we've seen raised before:
On the So-Called “Choice-in-Dying”
Naturally Horn presents a one-sided view of the issue, though.
Monday, 4 August 2014
Estranged Notions: Richard Dawkins and the God of the Old Testament
Today's post:
Richard Dawkins and the God of the Old Testament
As usual, the elephant in the room goes unremarked: the Old Testament (specifically the parts under discussion here) is not factual history but propaganda. Evolution may be harsh and amoral, but it really happened; we are the result of hundreds of millions of years of tooth-and-claw survival. But rather than deify evolution and worship its values, we have the option—some would say the only right option on meeting a god—of killing it and taking its powers for our own use.
The Old Testament God has no such excuse. The stories of genocides were almost certainly not told because they actually happened, but rather because the compilers of the OT regarded these genocidal commands as being consistent with the kind of god that they wanted; they embraced the idea of slaughter rather than rejecting it. (Archaeology gives us a history of the Levant which is completely at odds with the OT stories until sometime after the time of Solomon; we obviously can't prove that something didn't happen, but we can establish that the context of the genocide stories does not fit with the historical context of any plausible time at which they could have occurred.)
So what path to choose? Worship of a God whose supposedly inspired literature contains fictional atrocities, or look at the cold facts of evolution and say, “yes, this is where we came from, and we need to understand the legacy it has left us; but it no longer dictates our future”?
Monday, 5 May 2014
Estranged Notions: Moral Relativism, Conscience, and G.E.M. Anscombe
Today's post: