Showing posts with label philosophy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label philosophy. Show all posts

Tuesday, 6 August 2019

Estranged Notions: “All Men Are Born Free By Nature”: Theological Conceptions of Freedom

Haven't done one of these in a while, and had stopped even checking SN for new content because it was all so boring, but I happened to notice this one and thought it was worth a bit of a teardown for the historical inaccuracies alone:

“All Men Are Born Free By Nature”: Theological Conceptions of Freedom

This one is by Tamer Nashef, whose bio says he's planning to write a book on this sort of thing; if this post is a representative example of his work, he seriously needs to improve his game.

Friday, 28 September 2018

Estranged Notions: The Big Problems with Naturalism

Posted on the 25th:

The Big Problems with Naturalism

This is Bonnette attacking metaphysical naturalism, using arguments many of which were dismantled in detail here in earlier discussions but which of course appear unchanged, without any acknowledgement of those criticisms. Reset button, anyone?

Thursday, 27 July 2017

Thursday, 4 February 2016

Estranged Notions: Modern Atheism: Dragging Plato Along Aristotle’s Coattails

Today's post:

Modern Atheism: Dragging Plato Along Aristotle’s Coattails

Gordon slobbers all over Aristotle while accusing all and sundry of not recognizing Plato's inadequacies; never mind that people reject Aristotle because he is wrong, not out of any regard for Plato. (Though one obvious thing that the two have in common is that neither had access to anything like enough raw facts to have any chance of reaching correct conclusions.)

Part of the problem with Aristotle is expressed in Boyden's review of Feser thus:

In this chapter, Feser discusses Plato and Aristotle. He accepts a fairly standard view on which Plato is the crazy metaphysician, and Aristotle tries to take the good parts of Plato's metaphysics and ground them with a healthy mix of common sense. As I understand it, this is roughly Aristotle's interpretation, and I think it has misleading aspects, but it's at least partly true. It's also why I like Plato better than Aristotle, which is of course the reverse of Feser's judgment. The problem with tempering your philosophy with common sense is that it's actually pretty common for common sense to be wrong, and if you make a mistake as a result of faulty common sense, people may fail to notice the mistake for centuries, or even millennia. On the other hand, if you make a mistake in your wild metaphysical flights of fancy, people are sure to call you on it, as they apparently did with Plato; the progression of the metaphysical theories in the dialogues seems to show that he was presented with a variety of criticisms, and tried to revise his theories in response to them.

When the universe turns out not to look anything like the common-sense version, then a commitment to ancient metaphysics becomes a liability.